Collagen for Scars: Supplements vs Proven Treatments

    Collagen for Scars: Supplements vs Proven Treatments

    No trial shows collagen supplements fade existing scars. Silicone gel is first line. Wound-healing studies, keloids, acne scars and collagen fillers explained.

    Written by Dimitrun Irene. Updated November 17, 2026.

    There is no clinical trial showing that collagen supplements fade existing scars, whether acne scars, surgical scars or keloids. We searched for one and found none as of November 2026. Oral collagen has been tested for healing wounds, mainly pressure ulcers and burns, with some positive but small and partly industry-funded results; that is not the same as improving a scar that has already formed. For raised scars, international guidelines name silicone gel or sheets as the first treatment, followed by steroid injections. It also helps to separate three things that share the word 'collagen': powders you swallow, collagen-containing medical products such as a dermal filler for acne scars and prescription wound dressings, and the collagen your own body lays down to form a scar. This guide explains each and what the evidence supports.

    Collagen for Scars: The Short Answer

    1. 1Existing scars: no trial of oral collagen for acne, surgical, hypertrophic or keloid scars has been found.
    2. 2Wound healing: small trials in pressure ulcers and burns suggest possible faster healing, often with industry funding.
    3. 3First-line care for raised scars: silicone gel or sheets, worn at least 12 hours a day for about two months.
    4. 4Keloids: steroid injections shrink them in 50% to 80% of cases, but many come back.
    5. 5Acne scars: dermatologists use fillers, microneedling, lasers and peels; one FDA-approved filler contains bovine collagen.
    6. 6See a dermatologist for any scar you do not remember getting, since skin cancer can look like a scar.

    Can Collagen Supplements Fade Scars?

    We found no evidence that they can. No randomized trial has tested oral collagen on existing acne scars, surgical scars, keloids or hypertrophic scars. Lab studies show that collagen fragments can affect fibroblasts, the skin cells that make collagen, but a 2024 systematic review of this research in Nutrients included only cell and animal studies and did not assess wound healing or scar outcomes in people. Lab findings often fail to carry over to people, so they cannot be used as proof. Product pages that claim collagen 'repairs' or 'erases' scars are going beyond the evidence. Collagen peptides themselves are explained in what are collagen peptides.

    Why Are Scars Made of Collagen in the First Place?

    When skin is injured deeply enough, the body repairs it by laying down new collagen. In a normal scar, this collagen is less organized than in healthy skin, which is why scars look and feel different. In a hypertrophic scar, the body makes too much collagen, producing a raised, firm scar that stays within the edges of the original wound. A keloid goes further, growing beyond the wound edges. In both cases the problem is excess, disorganized collagen, so 'more collagen' is not the goal. This is one reason the treatments with the best evidence work by flattening, softening or reducing scar tissue rather than adding collagen.

    Does Oral Collagen Help Wounds Heal?

    A few trials suggest it may help some wounds heal faster, though none measured long-term scar appearance as a main result:

    1. 1Pressure ulcers: Sugihara and colleagues (Scientific Reports, 2018) gave 120 patients with stage II to III pressure ulcers one of two collagen hydrolysate products, or placebo, on top of standard care for 16 weeks. At 16 weeks, ulcer severity scores (lower is better) were 6.46 and 8.21 with the two products, compared with 9.26 with placebo. The study was funded by the company that makes the products, and two company researchers were authors.
    2. 2Nursing-home residents: a secondary summary of a 2006 trial in 89 residents of 23 facilities reports that a fortified collagen protein product roughly doubled the improvement in pressure ulcer scores over 8 weeks compared with placebo. We could not read the original paper.
    3. 3Burns: a small pilot study (Burns, 2020) in 31 men with burns covering 20% to 30% of the body found faster wound healing with a collagen-based supplement than with a placebo of equal calories over 4 weeks. Hospital stay was shorter (9.4 versus 13.5 days), but that difference was not statistically significant.
    4. 4Burns and inflammation: a 2021 trial in 66 burn patients from Iran tested collagen hydrolysate with or without fish oil and reported on blood markers such as CRP and glucose. A secondary summary of the same group's research reports lower scar scores with collagen in 57 adults, but we could not confirm the original paper, so treat that finding with caution.

    These studies involved serious wounds and often people who were undernourished or recovering in hospital, where extra protein of any kind can matter. Whether healthy people healing from a cut or surgery would see less scarring is untested. Collagen around surgery is discussed in collagen after surgery.

    What Do Guidelines Recommend First for Raised Scars?

    International scar management recommendations published in 2002 by Mustoe and colleagues gave a primary role to silicone gel sheeting and steroid injections into the scar, calling them the only treatments with sufficient evidence at the time. Updated recommendations were published in 2014, and a 2016 summary of the update reported that silicone is the first intervention for preventing and treating hypertrophic and keloid scars, used at least 12 hours a day for two months. Steroid injections became second-line if there is no response after two months, and surgery is a last resort.

    The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) lists silicone gel sheets or ointment, used since 1982, as a scar treatment and says sheets appear to work better than gel. Other options on the AAD list include pressure therapy, polyurethane dressings, lasers, steroid injections (which can shrink a scar by more than half), injections of 5-fluorouracil or bleomycin, freezing (cryosurgery), surgery and radiation. The AAD also advises sunscreen with SPF 30 or higher on scars.

    Scar treatments by evidence

    Treatment
    Scar type
    Evidence
    Source

    Silicone gel or sheets

    Hypertrophic, keloid; prevention after surgery

    Guideline first line; Cochrane: weak but supportive (20 trials, 873 people)

    Mustoe 2002; 2016 update; Cochrane 2013

    Steroid injections

    Keloid, hypertrophic

    Shrink keloids in 50% to 80%; many regrow within 5 years

    AAD; 2016 update

    Pressure therapy

    Keloid (e.g. earlobe), raised scars

    Pressure earrings worn 12 to 20 hours a day for months

    AAD

    Surgery alone

    Keloid

    Keloids return in nearly 100% of cases

    AAD

    Fillers, microneedling, lasers, peels

    Acne scars

    Used by dermatologists; filler effects last 3 months to permanent

    AAD

    Onion extract, vitamin A or E creams

    Various

    Limited research

    AAD

    Oral collagen

    Existing scars

    No trials found

    This review of the literature

    How Strong Is the Evidence for Silicone?

    Silicone is the best-supported option, but the evidence is not perfect. A 2013 Cochrane review by O'Brien and Jones pooled 20 trials with 873 people. In people at high risk of abnormal scarring, silicone sheeting lowered the risk of developing a hypertrophic scar or keloid by about half (risk ratio 0.46, 95% confidence interval 0.21 to 0.98), and it reduced scar thickness and improved color. However, the trials were of poor quality with a high risk of bias, so the reviewers judged the evidence weak. That still puts silicone well ahead of oral collagen, which has no scar trials at all. The AAD notes that silicone sheets should not be placed on open wounds.

    How Do Dermatologists Treat Keloids?

    According to the AAD, steroid injections shrink keloids in 50% to 80% of patients, but many keloids regrow within five years. Surgery alone is rarely enough: keloids come back in nearly 100% of cases, so surgery is usually combined with other treatments. Pressure earrings, worn 12 to 20 hours a day for months, are used for earlobe keloids. Silicone sheets are also used once the skin has closed. No collagen supplement is part of keloid treatment, and because keloids are made of excess collagen, there is no logical reason to expect one to help.

    What Helps Acne Scars?

    The AAD lists several in-office treatments for acne scars: fillers, which last from three months to permanently depending on the type; microneedling, sometimes called 'collagen induction therapy' because tiny needle wounds prompt the skin to make new collagen; lasers; chemical peels; radiofrequency; platelet-rich plasma; and minor surgery. For mild scarring, a topical retinoid may help. The best option depends on the type of scar, so a dermatologist's assessment is the place to start. Whether collagen supplements affect acne itself is covered in does collagen cause acne.

    What Are Collagen Fillers and Collagen Dressings, and How Are They Different From Powders?

    Several regulated medical products contain collagen, and their evidence does not transfer to supplements:

    1. 1Collagen-containing filler: the FDA's list of approved dermal filler materials includes PMMA beads (tiny plastic microspheres) in a gel containing bovine collagen. FDA labeling for one such device, Bellafill, covers moderate to severe, depressed acne scars on the cheek in people over 21, and requires a skin test first. It is injected by a clinician.
    2. 2Collagen wound dressings: the FDA classifies 'Dressing, Wound, Collagen' as a prescription device used for pressure, diabetic and venous ulcers, skin graft donor sites and burns. These are applied to the wound, not swallowed.
    3. 3Microneedling: called collagen induction therapy, it stimulates your own skin to make collagen and involves no collagen product at all.
    4. 4Collagen powders and capsules: dietary supplements, which are not approved by the FDA for any medical use and have no scar trials.

    Products called 'collagen' compared

    Product
    What it is
    How it is regulated
    Evidence for scars

    Collagen powder or capsules

    Hydrolyzed collagen peptides taken by mouth

    Dietary supplement

    No trials on existing scars

    Collagen-PMMA filler

    Bovine collagen gel with PMMA microspheres, injected

    FDA-approved device (premarket approval)

    Labeled for moderate to severe atrophic acne scars on the cheek

    Collagen wound dressing

    Collagen material applied to open wounds

    FDA prescription device

    Used for wound care, not for treating existing scars

    Microneedling

    Tiny needle punctures that prompt new collagen

    Procedure performed by clinicians

    Listed by the AAD for acne scars

    Do Collagen Creams Help Scars?

    We found no good evidence that collagen in a cream improves scars, and no primary source showing that collagen applied to the skin passes into deeper layers where scars form. The AAD says over-the-counter scar products, such as onion extract or vitamin A or E, have limited research behind them. If you want a product to use at home on a raised scar, silicone gel or sheets have far better support. Collagen and skin creams for aging are covered in collagen for wrinkles.

    When Should You See a Dermatologist About a Scar?

    The AAD advises seeing a dermatologist for any scar you do not remember getting, because some skin cancers can look like a scar. A dermatologist can also tell a hypertrophic scar from a keloid, which changes the treatment plan.

    When to Talk to Your Doctor

    1. 1A scar or scar-like spot that appeared without an injury you remember
    2. 2A scar that is growing beyond the original wound, itching, painful or limiting movement
    3. 3A wound that is slow to heal, red, warm or draining, which may be infected
    4. 4A personal or family history of keloids before planned surgery or piercing
    5. 5Before taking supplements if you have kidney disease, allergies or are pregnant; see collagen peptides side effects

    What to Do Next: Questions to Ask Your Doctor

    1. 1What type of scar do I have: normal, hypertrophic, keloid or atrophic (depressed)?
    2. 2Should I start silicone gel or sheets, and when, for how long each day?
    3. 3Would steroid injections, pressure therapy or laser treatment suit my scar?
    4. 4For acne scars, which procedure fits my scar type and skin tone?
    5. 5Is my diet giving me enough protein and vitamin C for healing after surgery?

    Vitamin C's role in the body's own collagen production is covered in collagen and vitamin C.

    The Bottom Line

    No trial has shown that collagen supplements fade existing scars. Small trials suggest oral collagen might speed healing of pressure ulcers and burns, but those were not scar studies and several had industry funding. For raised scars, silicone gel or sheets are the first-line treatment, with steroid injections next, and acne scars respond to in-office procedures. Collagen medical products, such as a collagen-containing filler and wound dressings, are different from supplements and should not be confused with them. If a scar bothers you, a dermatologist is the best next step.

    FAQ

    Collagen supplements have not been tested on acne scars. Dermatologists treat them with fillers, microneedling, lasers and peels; one FDA-approved filler contains bovine collagen.

    There is no evidence they can. Keloids are made of excess collagen, and silicone and steroid injections are the established treatments.

    Yes. Silicone is the guideline first-line treatment for raised scars, supported by trials, while oral collagen has no scar trials.

    No trial shows it reduces surgical scars. Eat enough protein and follow your surgeon's wound care advice; see collagen after surgery.

    One FDA-approved filler containing bovine collagen and PMMA is labeled for moderate to severe depressed acne scars on the cheek. It requires a skin test first.

    Evidence is limited; see collagen for stretch marks for what the studies show.

    Sources

    1. 1Sugihara F, Inoue N, Venkateswarathirukumara S. Ingestion of bioactive collagen hydrolysates enhanced pressure ulcer healing in a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled clinical study, Scientific Reports, 2018
    2. 2The effect of a hydrolyzed collagen-based supplement on wound healing in patients with burn: a randomized double-blind pilot clinical trial, Burns, 2020
    3. 3Alipoor E, Hosseinzadeh-Attar MJ, Salehi S, et al. Effect of collagen hydrolysate and fish oil on high-sensitivity C-reactive protein and glucose homeostasis in patients with severe burn: a randomized clinical trial, Archives of Academic Emergency Medicine, 2021
    4. 4Inacio PAQ, Chaluppe FA, Aguiar GF, et al. Effects of hydrolyzed collagen as a dietary supplement on fibroblast activation: a systematic review, Nutrients, 2024
    5. 5Mustoe TA et al. International clinical recommendations on scar management, Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2002
    6. 6Gold MH et al. Updated international clinical recommendations on scar management: part 1, evaluating the evidence, Dermatologic Surgery, 2014
    7. 7Gold MH et al. Updated international clinical recommendations on scar management: part 2, algorithms for scar prevention and treatment, Dermatologic Surgery, 2014
    8. 8O'Brien L, Jones DJ. Silicone gel sheeting for preventing and treating hypertrophic and keloid scars, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2013
    9. 9FDA-approved dermal fillers, US Food and Drug Administration, 2020
    10. 10Patient labeling, PMA P020012/S009 (collagen-PMMA dermal filler), US Food and Drug Administration
    11. 11Scars: diagnosis and treatment, American Academy of Dermatology
    12. 12Scars, American Academy of Dermatology
    13. 13Keloids: diagnosis and treatment, American Academy of Dermatology, 2023
    14. 14Acne scars: diagnosis and treatment, American Academy of Dermatology, 2023
    15. 15Scars: updated management recommendations, HCPLive, 2016
    16. 16The role of nutrition in treating and healing wounds (summary of Lee SK et al., 2006), I Advance Senior Care
    17. 17FDA 510(k) record K120250, product code KGN (collagen wound dressing), third-party mirror of FDA data, Innolitics

    This article summarizes published research for general information and is not medical advice. The pressure ulcer trial cited was funded by the maker of the collagen products tested.

    Dimitrun Irene

    Author

    Published November 17, 2026
    Share:TwitterFacebook

    Comments (0)

    Be the first to comment on this article.

    More articles

    How Long Do Collagen Peptides Take to Work